Participants in clinical trials value personalized, accurate information about study results
Flip open any biology textbook and you’re bound to see a complicated diagram of the inner workings of a cell, with its internal scaffolding, the cytoskeleton, and how it maintains a cell’s shape. Yet the fundamental question remains, which came first: the shape, or the skeleton? Now a research team led by Phong Tran, PhD,
Full Post: Scientists find cells reorganize shape to fit situation
Participants in clinical trials report being satisfied with personalized, accurate communication of results by study investigators soon after the study findings are released publicly, according to a report in the December issue of Archives of Neurology.
Even though volunteers in clinical trials expose themselves to risk, there is no legal mandate for investigators to inform participants of study results, according to background information in the article. However, many researchers have recommended providing both negative and positive clinical trial results as the “ethical norm.” “Despite this recommendation, efforts to communicate results to research participants remain quite limited,” the authors write. “Some participants never learn study results, although many would like to have that information.”
E. Ray Dorsey, M.D., M.B.A., of University of Rochester Medical Center, New York, and colleagues conducted a multi-site randomized clinical trial of an omega-three fatty acid for patients with mild to moderate Huntington’s disease. Following the completion of the trial, the researchers implemented a communication plan with three principal elements: a media release from the study investigators, posted online and e-mailed to members of the Huntington’s disease community; a telephone call from the site staff to research participants; and a conference call for investigators, sponsor and study participants two weeks after the results were released.
A total of 217 study participants were mailed a survey to assess their satisfaction with the communication of the results; 114 (52.5 percent) responded. “Most (73.1 percent) first learned the study results from their site’s telephone call, and 46.3 percent learned the results within one day of the sponsor’s press release,” the authors write. “Participants reported high or complete satisfaction with the site telephone call (89.3 percent) and conference call (82.1 percent) but relatively low satisfaction with the sponsor’s press release (50 percent). Most respondents reported good understanding of the risks and benefits of the experimental treatment and the next steps for their participation.”
When asked whether they prefer that results undergo a thorough review before being informed, 59.4 percent agreed, even if it meant a delay in learning about the results. They also reported preferring communications customized to them rather than directed to the public or company investors.
“Communicating research results to participants remains an unmet need that would likely benefit from more planning and cooperation, from addressing the issue prospectively in the consent process, and from using a more evidence-based appraisal of clinical research practices,” the authors conclude. “Our study suggests that addressing this need is feasible and highly valued by research participants.”
While an estimated 2.3 million people in the U.S. take part in clinical trials every year, there currently exists no formal requirement to inform them of study results; an oversight that leaves participants confused, frustrated, and, in some cases, lacking information that may be important to their health. In an article published in the Archives
Full Post: Novel approach to disseminate trial results to study volunteers
Face-to-face and telephone follow-up sessions appear to be more effective in the maintenance of weight loss for women from rural communities compared with weight loss education alone, according to a report in the November 24 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine. In addition, telephone counseling appears to be just as effective as face-to-to face counseling
Full Post: Telephone counseling may be as effective as face-to-face counseling in weight loss maintenance
New data from The Kinsey Institute at Indiana University demonstrate that many women think condoms undermine sexual pleasure, but those who use both hormonal contraception and condoms report higher overall sexual satisfaction. The study authors suggest that this inconsistency reflects how women think about their contraceptive method when asked questions about two different aspects of
Full Post: Contraceptive methods and women’s sexuality
Addressing the nation’s continuing poor performance in cancer clinical trial participation, particularly among racial and ethnic minorities and low income groups, will require meaningful public involvement in the design and implementation of clinical trials, according to a landmark report released today. Despite many previous calls for community participation and engagement, Communities as Partners in Cancer
Full Post: National call for cancer trial system to be more responsive to community needs
Total knee replacement (TKR) is a common treatment for osteoarthritis, a disease affecting more than 20 million Americans. However, the surgery poses risks and both patients and physicians must carefully assess its potential benefits and harm. Studies have shown that doctor-patient communication is correlated with outcomes and that patient satisfaction and commitment to treatment are
Full Post: Health-care providers and patients differ on views of knee replacement